Simon Cowell (June 2009)
Yes, that Simon Cowell. In a remarkable piece for Britain’s Daily Mail, Cowell engaged
in an honest and thorough critique of his conduct during the recently
completed season of “Britain’s Got Talent,” concluding
that he had made several errors. Among them: being too harsh in his
live criticism of a child contestant, and not being sufficiently protective
of the break-out phenomenon of the competition, the unlikely Scottish
song-bird Susan Boyle. Cowell writes that in the matter of Boyle, he doesn’t know what
he could have done that would have worked out better (Boyle had an emotional
breakdown shortly after the final show), but that he still accepts responsibility
for not protecting her from the ravages of sudden celebrity. It is admirable
is that Cowell really tries to analyze what other, more ethical options
he might have taken in several scenarios during the program. In one case, I would suggest that a decision he seems to be proud of
was in fact the wrong one: when a 10-year-old forgot her lyrics and
collapsed in tears on national TV, Cowell bent the rules and gave her
a chance to come back and try again. Nice, kind…but unfair. If children
are going to compete on a level playing field with adults, as they do
on “Britain’s Got Talent,” they out to forfeit any special
considerations due to their age. Cowell seems puzzled that he received
criticism for having mercy on the young contestant. “In this instance,
I thought giving Hollie a second chance was the right thing to do,”
he writes. “Yet, ironically, I have had more complaints about Hollie
being allowed to perform twice than anything else on the show. Isn’t
that incredible? It’s certainly very confusing. Sometimes, you are damned
if you do and damned if you don’t.” Welcome to my world, Simon. It is important, therefore, to go back
and think such dilemmas through, using ethical principles to assess
intentions and results, so better decisions can result the next time.
Most of us don’t take the time to do this as frequently as we should.
Simon Cowell, of all people, has shown that while he may not always
have the most ethical instincts, he’s trying to improve. Ultimately that’s all any of us can do.
|
© 2007 Jack Marshall & ProEthics,
Ltd |